58 Oyster Bluff, Chatham, MA 02633 (MLS# 22504136)
58 Oyster Bluff, Chatham, MA 02633
$5,805,000
Property Type:
Residential
Bedrooms:
7
Baths:
4
Square Footage:
3,734
Lot Size (sq. ft.):
40,473
Status:
Closed
Current Price:
$5,805,000
List Date:
9/19/2025
Last Modified:
12/19/2025
Overview
Description
Perched high above Oyster Pond, this generational estate—first known as ''The Beach Plum House'' and later as ''Adsamore''—is one of Chatham's rarest offerings. Set on a remarkable .93-acre parcel with expansive frontage, it offers sweeping views of town and Oyster Pond, a lifestyle at once connected and secluded. Originally built in Wellfleet as the Captain Holbrook House, the home has been lovingly preserved and expanded over time while being modernized for hosting and gathering. The seven bedrooms include a private first-floor primary suite with walk-in closet and ensuite bath, while a Good Morning staircase, adorned with a hand-painted Chatham mural, leads to the upper level bedrooms. Historic character endures throughout: the wood room with elements from the Plymouth Cordage Co. ropewalk (circa 1824), hand-hewn structural beams, herringbone brick floors, central hearths, and authentic built-ins. Outside, brick patios, mature sycamore trees, granite steps, and rock walls frame rolling lawns that meet the water's edge, where a private catwalk and moorings await. Spacious yet intimate, this is a true legacy property—an irreplaceable waterfront setting ready for its next steward.
Listing Details MLS# 22504136
Contract Info
- Original List Price
- 5750000
- List Price/SqFt
- 1539.9
Legal and Taxes
- Street #
- 58
- Street Name
- Oyster Bluff
- County
- Barnstable
- Town
- Chatham
- Village
- Chatham
- State
- MA
- Zip Code
- 02633
- Tax ID
- 13E-66-H9
- Estimated Annual Taxes
- 15095
- Tax Year
- 2025
- Building Assessments
- 824900
- Other Assessments
- 134200
- Total Assessment
- 4350300
- Title Reference - Book
- 9219
- Title Reference - Page
- 171
- Lead Base Paint
- Unknown
- Flood Ins Required
- Yes: verify w/insurance agent
- Mass Use Code
- 101 - Residential, single family
- Nitrogen Sensitive Area
- Yes
General Property Info
- Region
- Lower Cape
- School District
- Monomoy
- Zoning
- R40
- Property Sub-Type
- Single Family Residence
- Year Built
- 1930
- Renovated
- No
- Total Finished Space
- 3734
- Field Card SqFt
- 3734
- Total Rooms
- 12
- Stories
- 2
- Private Pool
- No
- Private Dock
- No
- Leased Land
- No
- Lot Size SqFt
- 40473
- Lot Size Source
- Field Card
- Acres
- 0.93
- Garage
- Yes
- # of Cars
- 2
- Year Round
- Yes
- Bedrooms - Total
- 7
- Baths - Full
- 3
- Baths - Half
- Yes
- Baths - Total
- 4
- Golf Course Front
- No
- Golf Course View
- No
- Waterfront
- Yes
- Water Body
- Oyster Pond
- Waterfront Type
- Lake/Pond
- Water Body Type
- Salt
- Water Access Type
- Private
- Waterview
- Yes
- Water Body View
- Oyster Pond
- Waterview Type
- Lake/Pond
- Property Includes Recording Devices
- No
- Basement
- Yes
Status Change Info
- Concessions
- No
- Estimated Selling Date
- 2025-12-18
- Under Contract Date
- 2025-09-19
- Sold Date
- 2025-12-18
- Sold Price/SqFt
- 1554.63
- SP/AV
- 1.33
Sewer
- Septic Tank
- Title V Grade Level
Remarks & Misc
- Public Remarks
- Perched high above Oyster Pond, this generational estate—first known as ''The Beach Plum House'' and later as ''Adsamore''—is one of Chatham's rarest offerings. Set on a remarkable .93-acre parcel with expansive frontage, it offers sweeping views of town and Oyster Pond, a lifestyle at once connected and secluded. Originally built in Wellfleet as the Captain Holbrook House, the home has been lovingly preserved and expanded over time while being modernized for hosting and gathering. The seven bedrooms include a private first-floor primary suite with walk-in closet and ensuite bath, while a Good Morning staircase, adorned with a hand-painted Chatham mural, leads to the upper level bedrooms. Historic character endures throughout: the wood room with elements from the Plymouth Cordage Co. ropewalk (circa 1824), hand-hewn structural beams, herringbone brick floors, central hearths, and authentic built-ins. Outside, brick patios, mature sycamore trees, granite steps, and rock walls frame rolling lawns that meet the water's edge, where a private catwalk and moorings await. Spacious yet intimate, this is a true legacy property—an irreplaceable waterfront setting ready for its next steward.
- Directions to Property
- Oyster Pond Furlong to Absegami Run. Left onto Oyster Bluff. 58 is on the cul de sac
More Information
Street Description
- Cul-De-Sac
- Yes
- Paved
- Yes
Special Listing Cond
- None
- Yes
Year Built Desc
- Approximate
- Yes
Basement Description
- Bulkhead Access
- Yes
Architectural Style
- Antique
- Yes
- Cape Cod
- Yes
Foundation Details
- Block
- Yes
Floors
- Wood
- Yes
- Other
- Yes
Roof Description
- Asphalt
- Yes
Siding Description
- Clapboard
- Yes
Heating
- Hot Water
- Yes
Cooling
- None
- Yes
Fuel Type
- Natural Gas
- Yes
Water
- Public
- Yes
Hot Water
- Water Heater
- Yes
Hot Water Source
- Oil
- Yes
Exterior Features
- Garden
- Yes
- Outdoor Shower
- Yes
- Private Yard
- Yes
- Underground Sprinkler System
- Yes
Property Features
Street Description:
Cul-De-Sac; Paved
Special Listing Cond:
None
Architectural Style:
Antique; Cape Cod
Year Built Desc:
Approximate
Basement Description:
Bulkhead Access
Foundation Details:
Block
Floors:
Wood; Other
Exterior Features:
Garden; Outdoor Shower; Private Yard; Underground Sprinkler System
Roof Description:
Asphalt
Siding Description:
Clapboard
Heating:
Hot Water
Cooling:
None
Fuel Type:
Natural Gas
Water:
Public
Hot Water:
Water Heater
Hot Water Source:
Oil
Documents
Lead Paint Disclosure ›
Listing Office:
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Robert Paul Properties
Listing Agent:
Guthrie Schofield Group
Last Updated: December - 19 - 2025
All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc include the name of the listing company. Neither the listing company nor CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. This site was last updated 02/14/2017. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal. Copyright 2020© Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved