31 Josiah Sachem Way, West Tisbury, MA 02575 (MLS# 22605167)

31 Josiah Sachem Way, West Tisbury, MA 02575

$3,790,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 7 Baths: 5 Square Footage: 4,464 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 135,036 Status: Active
Current Price: $3,790,000 List Date: 10/09/2026 Last Modified: 10/11/2026

Overview

Description

THE COMPOUND AT INDIAN HILL Three dwellings. One price. One house decides how you live. Three let you change your mind. More than three private acres in West Tisbury. 4,464 square feet across three buildings, each with its own front door. The Main House holds the center. Glass doors & generous windows pull the meadow inside. A stone fireplace anchors the room. The kitchen was built for dinners that run long. The Studio Barn is the open question. Four sets of French doors swing wide to a wildflower meadow, & the room goes with them. Artist's studio. Wellness space. Whatever you have been missing. The Guest House earns its keep. Three bedrooms, a loft-inspired living space, & a long rental history. Seven bedrooms. Four & a half baths. A heated saltwater pool. A full compound, or a primary residence with income built in. Lambert's Cove & Long Point beaches, farm stands, & Cedar Tree Neck Sanctuary. Walk to the market, apothecary, & post office. Rural enough to disappear into. Close e ...

Supplements: On the gentle slopes of Indian Hill, more than three private acres hold a main house, a studio barn, & a guest house. 4,464 square feet in all. Wildflower meadows run between them. Layered perennial gardens soften the edges. A heated saltwater pool sits at the center, looking borrowed from a private resort. This is not a house with outbuildings. I ...

Listing Details MLS# 22605167

Contract Info

Original List Price
3790000
List Price/SqFt
849.01

Legal and Taxes

Street #
31
Street Name
Josiah Sachem
Street Suffix
Way
County
Dukes
Town
West Tisbury
Village
West Tisbury
State
MA
Zip Code
02575
Tax ID
WTIS M:16 B: L:90 U:
Estimated Annual Taxes
11390
Tax Year
2026
Building Assessments
1241500
Total Assessment
2186100
Title Reference - Book
1598
Title Reference - Page
995
Underground Fuel Tank
Unknown
Lead Base Paint
Unknown
Asbestos
Unknown
Flood Ins Required
Not Verified
Mass Use Code
109 - Residential, multiple houses

General Property Info

Comp Sale YN
No
Region
Dukes County
School District
Martha's Vineyard
Zoning
RU
Property Sub-Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1972
Renovated
Yes
Renovated Comments
Bathroom renovations, system upgrades, window upgrades, enhancements to pool, landscape, a major renovation to the studio barn to create living space out of a horse barn and garage.
Total Finished Space
4464
Field Card SqFt
2088
Additional Finished Space
2376
Additional SqFt Source
Public Records
Total Rooms
15
Stories
Yes
Style
Ranch
Private Pool
Yes
Private Dock
No
Leased Land
No
Lot Size SqFt
135036
Lot Size Source
Assessor
Acres
3.1
Garage
No
# of Parking Spaces
10
Year Round
Yes
Bedrooms - Total
7
Baths - Full
4
Baths - Half
Yes
Baths - Total
5
Separate Living Qtrs
Yes
Golf Course Front
No
Golf Course View
No
Waterfront
No
Waterview
No
Miles to Beach
2 Plus
Mi. to Beach Comments
2.5 Miles to Lambert's Cove Beach.
Fireplace
Yes
# Fireplaces
Yes
Property Includes Recording Devices
No

Sep Living Qtrs Info

Beds
3
Baths - Full
Yes
Baths - Half
Yes
Baths - Total
2
Type
Guest House

Convenient To

Convenient to Water Body 1
Vineyard Sound
Convenient to Water Body 2
Nantucket Sound
Convenient to Water Body 3
Atlantic Ocean

Sewer

Septic Tank Description
Title V Grade Level

More Information

DPR Eligibility

DPR Eligible
No

Room Types

Bedroom 2 Level
First
Bedroom 3 Level
First
Den Level
First
Dining Room Level
First
Kitchen Level
First
Living Room Level
First
Office Level
First
Primary Bathroom Level
First
Primary Bedroom Level
First

Property Features

Street Description: Dead End Street; Dirt; Public; Unpaved Special Listing Cond: Standard Architectural Style: Ranch Year Built Desc: Approximate Basement Description: Bulkhead Access; Interior Access; Partial Foundation Details: Poured Lot Features: Level Parking Features: Driveway; Gravel Separate Living Qtrs: Detached Waterview Direction: All Appliances: Countertop Range; Dishwasher; Freezer; Gas Range; Microwave; Refrigerator; Wall/Oven Cook Top; Washer; Washer/Dryer Stacked; Wine Cooler Floors: Tile; Wood Interior Features: Entrance Foyer; Linen Closet; Mud Room; Recessed Lighting Patio And Porch Features: Deck Private Pool Description: Covered; Heated; In Ground Other Structures: Other Exterior Features: Outdoor Shower; Private Yard Fencing: None Roof Description: Pitched; Shingle Siding Description: Shingle; Wood Siding Sewer: Septic Tank Heating: Forced Air; Heat Pump Cooling: Central Air; Other Fuel Type: Propane Water: Well Hot Water: Tankless Water Heater; Water Heater Hot Water Source: Propane Gas Room Types: Bathroom 2; Bathroom 3; Bedroom 2; Bedroom 3; Den; Dining Room; Family Room; Kitchen; Living Room; Office; Primary Bathroom; Primary Bedroom

Room Information

Room Name Level
Living Room First
Dining Room First
Kitchen First
Den First
Office First
Primary Bedroom First
Primary Bathroom First
Bedroom 2 First
Bedroom 3 First
IDX
Listing Office: Studio Realty LLC
Listing Agent: Peyton Wallace
Source MLS Verified
Last Updated: October - 11 - 2026
All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc include the name of the listing company. Neither the listing company nor CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. This site was last updated 02/14/2017. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal. Copyright 2020© Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved