17 Church Street, Yarmouth Port, MA 02675 (MLS# 22500285)

17 Church Street, Yarmouth Port, MA 02675

$1,754,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 3 Baths: 4 Square Footage: 3,442 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 10,454 Status: Closed
Current Price: $1,754,000 List Date: 1/27/2025 Last Modified: 6/04/2025

Description

A Once-in-a-Lifetime Historic Home, Artfully Restored and Imbued with Timeless Charm. Nestled amidst a magical cottage garden, this extraordinary property seamlessly blends history, artistry and architectural authenticity. Originally built in 1836 as a church, the structure is an exquisite example of Gothic Revival design, complete with soaring pointed-arch fenestration that imbues the space with both light and drama. The addition of an ell in 1934 introduced a thoughtfully-designed kitchen where vintage features meet updated appliances. Also included in the ell are three beautifully-appointed bedrooms, each with its own private bath. The dining/sitting area, with its breathtaking two-story Gothic Revival window, serves as an awe-inspiring gathering space. In 1973, the visionary set designers Herbert Senn and Helen Pond, inspired by the enchanting Strawberry Hill House in Twickenham, England, purchased the property and infused it with their remarkable trompe-l'oeil artistry. The effect is nothing short of mesmerizing, as painted details subtly enhance the architecture and breathe new life into the interiors. The large hall, a true showstopper, is home to one of New England's

Supplements: oldest working organs, paired with the warmth and charm of a Ben Franklin fireplace. When the electrified gas lanterns, with their brass reflectors, cast their soft glow across the space, it's easy to imagine being transported to another time entirely. The current owners have been devoted custodians of this rare gem, carefully restoring its historical elements while thoughtfully incorporating modern amenities. The tower clock, previously silent, ticks away once more. A comprehensive list of updates is available, showcasing the loving care taken to preserve the home's legacy while enhancing its livability for today's lifestyle. This property isn't just a home, it's a living piece of history where the past and present converge in the most stunning of settings.

More Information MLS# 22500285

Contract Info

List Price/SqFt: 549.1 Status: Closed Original List Price: 1990000 Sold Price: $1,754,000 Current Price: $1,754,000 List Date: 2025-01-27

Legal and Taxes

Town: Yarmouth Village: Yarmouth Port Estimated Annual Taxes: 7411 Building Assessments: 750400 Other Assessments: 0 Total Assessment: 1046800 Title Reference - Book: C218734 Underground Fuel Tank: Unknown Flood Ins Required: No Lead Base Paint: Unknown Mass Use Code: 101 - Residential, single family Nitrogen Sensitive Area: No Street #: 17 Street Name: Church Street Suffix: Street County: Barnstable State: MA Zip Code: 02675 Tax ID: 122-66 Tax Year: 2025

General Property Info

Region: Mid-Cape School District: Dennis-Yarmouth Zoning: Residential Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence Renovated: Yes Stories: 2 Total Rooms: 6 Field Card SqFt: 3442 Basement: Yes Baths - Half: 1 Private Dock: No Private Pool: No Lot Size SqFt: 10454 Leased Land: No Lot Size Source: Field Card Acres: 0.24 Irregular: Yes Garage: No # of Parking Spaces: 4 Year Round: Yes Separate Living Qtrs: No Golf Course Front: No Golf Course View: No Waterfront: No Waterview: No Miles to Beach: 1 to 2 Mi. to Beach Comments: Gray's Beach Fireplace: Yes # Fireplaces: 1 Property Includes Recording Devices: No Year Built: 1836 Total Finished Space: 3442 Bedrooms - Total: 3 Baths - Full: 3 Baths - Total: 4

Remarks & Misc

Public Remarks: A Once-in-a-Lifetime Historic Home, Artfully Restored and Imbued with Timeless Charm. Nestled amidst a magical cottage garden, this extraordinary property seamlessly blends history, artistry and architectural authenticity. Originally built in 1836 as a church, the structure is an exquisite example of Gothic Revival design, complete with soaring pointed-arch fenestration that imbues the space with both light and drama. The addition of an ell in 1934 introduced a thoughtfully-designed kitchen where vintage features meet updated appliances. Also included in the ell are three beautifully-appointed bedrooms, each with its own private bath. The dining/sitting area, with its breathtaking two-story Gothic Revival window, serves as an awe-inspiring gathering space. In 1973, the visionary set designers Herbert Senn and Helen Pond, inspired by the enchanting Strawberry Hill House in Twickenham, England, purchased the property and infused it with their remarkable trompe-l'oeil artistry. The effect is nothing short of mesmerizing, as painted details subtly enhance the architecture and breathe new life into the interiors. The large hall, a true showstopper, is home to one of New England's Directions to Property: Route 6A to Church St. House is on the left

Status Change Info

Concessions: No Estimated Selling Date: 2025-06-04 Sold Price/SqFt: 509.59 SP/AV: 1.68 Under Contract Date: 2025-04-23 Sold Date: 2025-06-04 Sold Price: $1,754,000

Street Description

Public: 1

Special Listing Cond

None: 1

Location Description

North of 6A: 1

Year Built Desc

Approximate: 1

Basement Description

Interior Access: 1 Partial: 1

Parking Features

Gravel: 1

Architectural Style

Antique: 1

Baths Per Level

Baths - Level 1: 1.5 Baths - Level 2: 2

Foundation Details

Crawl Space: 1 Stone: 1

Convenient To

Conservation Area: 1 House of Worship: 1 In Town Location: 1 Shopping: 1 Convenient to Water Body 1: Gray's Beach

Floors

Wood: 1

Sewer

Septic Tank: Title V Grade Level

Roof Description

Asphalt: 1

Siding Description

Clapboard: 1

Primary Bedroom

Primary Bedroom: 1 Primary Bedroom Level: First Floor Balcony: 1 Flooring: Wood Private Full Bath: 1

Heating

Forced Air: 1 Heat Pump: 1

Bedroom 2

Bedroom 2 Level: Second Floor Flooring: Wood Private Full Bath: 1

Cooling

Central Air: 1 Other: 1

Bedroom 3

Bedroom 3 Level: Second Floor Private Full Bath: 1

Fuel Type

Natural Gas: 1

Water

Public: 1

Hot Water

Tankless Water Heater: 1

Foyer

Foyer Level: First Floor Shared Half Bath: 1

Hot Water Source

Natural Gas: 1

Laundry Room

Laundry Room: 1 Laundry Room Level: First Floor

Living/Dining Combo

Yes: 1

Living Room

Living Room: 1 Living Room Level: First Floor Cathedral Ceiling: 1 Fireplace: Wood Burning Flooring: Wood

Dining Room

Dining Room Level: First Floor Cathedral Ceiling: 1 Flooring: Wood

Kitchen/Dining Combo

Yes: 1

Kitchen

Kitchen: 1 Kitchen Level: First Floor Flooring: Wood

Other Room 1

Room Type: Sitting Room Level: First Floor

Exterior Features

Garden: 1

Other Room 2

Room Type: Loft Level: Second Floor

Appliances

Electric Dryer: 1 Gas Range: 1 Refrigerator: 1 Washer: 1

Interior Features

Interior Balcony: 1

Patio And Porch Features

Deck: 1

Property Features

Street Description: Public Location Description: North of 6A Special Listing Cond: None Architectural Style: Antique Year Built Desc: Approximate Basement Description: Interior Access; Partial Foundation Details: Crawl Space; Stone Parking Features: Gravel Convenient To: Conservation Area; House of Worship; In Town Location; Shopping Primary Bedroom: Primary Bedroom; Balcony; Private Full Bath Bedroom 2: Private Full Bath Bedroom 3: Private Full Bath Foyer: Shared Half Bath Laundry Room: Laundry Room Living Room: Living Room; Cathedral Ceiling Dining Room: Cathedral Ceiling Kitchen: Kitchen Appliances: Electric Dryer; Gas Range; Refrigerator; Washer Floors: Wood Interior Features: Interior Balcony Patio And Porch Features: Deck Exterior Features: Garden Roof Description: Asphalt Siding Description: Clapboard Heating: Forced Air; Heat Pump Cooling: Central Air; Other Fuel Type: Natural Gas Water: Public Hot Water: Tankless Water Heater Hot Water Source: Natural Gas
Listing Office: Sotheby's International Realty, Inc.
Listing Agent: Lisa R Hassler
IDX
Last Updated: June - 04 - 2025
All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc include the name of the listing company. Neither the listing company nor CC&I Assoc. of REALTORS, Inc shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. This site was last updated 02/14/2017. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal. Copyright 2020© Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved